jnusswrote a review of Evolv Shaman Climbing Shoe on May 15, 2014
Familiarity: I've used it several times
Fit: True to size
These things can make good footholds out of a lot of crappy stuff, sometimes nothing. So you could climb to the moon if you wanted.
They have good sticky rubber, that's durable furthermore. Me and my cousin both have em and they're great. The "love bump" took some getting used to I suppose, but it's been a non factor. It helps these shoes fit like a true glove. They are worth the cash. Plus, they are easy on and off with the wide opening and the three Velcro straps. I go two or three times a week and climb in a fairly sharp area, but they are holding up great thus far.
I usually wear a 11-11.5 street and got these in 11. They fit tight, but I prefer that. So, if you run about the same and don't like tight, then go up to the 11.5.