These boots are amazing! The color is really nice, I got the brown leather one. It's easy to match with other clothing and jeans. I've only had it for a 3 weeks and I've gotten so many compliments on them and people have asked me where I got them.
On the practical side, my feet are always the first to be cold in the winter season. Well, I've worn them in 20F degree weather now and my feet stay toasty. I'm very happy with the results! In addition to being really warm, they are also very comfortable (although you have to wait 'til the leather is stretched a little, so they may not be the most comfortable boots at first, which is true for real leather boots). I feel like I'm waking in my beloved Chaco sandals, except my feet and legs are covered. I've walked about 2 miles at a time in them in the city and my feet still feel amazing. They are also truly waterproof, which is useful for snow and ice cold rain.
Bottom line: I would recommend these boots for anyone looking for boots that have both style and comfort!