I gave it 3 stars if one was to purchase it full price. I bought it when it was on sale, so personally from my experience i would give it 4 stars.
I am typically size 7 and I ordered this shoes in size 9. It was still kinda small. But after a month of wearing it, either my foot got used to the pain or the shoes expanded; the shoes fit well now.
I had this shoes for about half a year now and I climb 3 times a week indoors. The shoes started showing signs of wear and tear after a few months, but it still functions well. So the cosmetic part of the shoe degraded pretty fast.
When I climb in this shoes, I feel secure with my foot on holds.
Overall, my climbing seems to be better with these shoes. The shoes start to look like it's falling apart early on, but still functions for at least 3 months after this. I'm happy with this shoes for the price I paid.