Masawrote a review of Mammut Magic Rope Bag on October 14, 2019
Familiarity: I've used it several times
I got it at a very good price so I shouldn’t complain, but the handle can be better. The short one doesn’t have any padding so it hurts your hand. The long one is a bit too long to hold with your hand, and somehow doesn’t fit my shoulder very well.
I like this as a nice gym bag, but if you want it as a rope bag, there could be a better one. If you fold and use it to put on the rope it is a bit small.
I am also a bit worried that it doesn’t have a strong corner to support the bag. I will have to see how durable this is.