Kylin Bwrote a review of Outdoor Research Verglas Gaiter - Women's on February 23, 2018
Familiarity: I've used it several times
I have used these in various conditions including snow, rain, and sunshine. They have worked great so far in terms of staying on and keeping debris out of my shoes. I also like that they add a layer of warmth to my feet so I often wear them when I really do not need to. There is a little clip at the boot end to secure the gaiter to the laces but I don't really use it because the gaiter stays pretty well.
The only complaint I have is with the leg strap, which others have complained about as well. It can be hard to get it tight enough to stay up so I can see how people with smaller calves might have trouble with cinching it. And once you do cinch it, there is no where to store the strap so it just hangs off the calves flapping in the wind. I like to stuff through the velcro because I don't like to seeing it flying around. Other than that, these are great and have served me well!