Not perfect, but very good.

By scott1770688 Ranked #847 - Men's Casual Shoes May 1, 2008

Very good shoes but not perfect. Good: looks (my 14 year old daughter even thinks they look cool on me, which is rare praise); sole (this may sound a little strange, but not only are they grippy, but they're super stable -- definitely a shoe made by a good boot company); finish (cool sort of roughout); fit (thermoformable insole -- really high-end detail for a relatively inexpensive shoe!).

Weak spots: because it laces down farther than an oxford but shorter than a tennis shoe, it flexes right behind the toes, which was uncomfortable for me until they broke in a little. And the tongue, which is thin, keeps shifting off-center and kind of crumpling up; I wish they had a fixed tongue. So: very good, not perfect, but I'll still recommend them.

View Details: Montrail Whidbey Shoe - Men's

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes