TNF Prism Optimus - nice but severely flawed

By Fred Ranked #682 - Men's Down Jackets November 1, 2009

I bought one of these almost a year ago.

Pros:

Very lightweight

Very compressible and portable

Welded construction means very few stitched seams and therefore minimal egress of goosedown from the jacket.

Nice overal quality of manufacture.

Doesn't make you look like a blimp when you wear it (both due to the welded construction and due to the efficient use of down, rather than highly-stuffed).

Cons:

The DWR coating lasts a few months at most before it becomes useless (unless you get the jacket professionally cleaned and treated regularly, which, let's face it, very few people do).

Mountain-Equipment make some of their down jackets (e.g. 'Annapurna', 'Greenland') with a clever elasticated system which holds the inner layer of the jacket close to the body, thus dramatically increasing the efficiency with which the jacket can insulate the body. Not so TNF - this jacket loses masses of efficiency when I wear it because although I have moderately long arms (necessitating a reasonably large jacket), I am of slim build.
...And therein lies a critical point - this jacket is billed by TNF as being part of their so-called 'Summit Series' - supposedly designed in close consultation with mountaineers. Am I to believe that all the mountaineers they allegedly consulted were NOT of athletic build, but rather of a more rotund, relatively-unfit build? Or did they all have short stubby arms, allowing them to fit into a small size jacket? Well, I'll concede that this is a personal thing, so I recommend that you try the jacket on before purchasing it; it might fit your body proportions perfectly.

If you take a CLOSE look at the photograph of the jacket, you can see that the sides of the hood do not draw in towards the chin - instead, they are cut so as to go straight down to the collar/shoulders of the jacket. Unfortunately, I did not notice this when I bought mine in the UK. The result of this horrendous design flaw is that the jacket is reasonably warm on a still day, but as soon as a breeze of as little as 10-15mph gets up, it rushes straight into the hood, past your cheeks, and down through the collar, chilling your entire body to the core and flushing out the warm body heat through the bottom of the jacket. It beggars belief that this jacket was designed with any consultation whatsoever with mountaineers!

I reported this glaring design flaw to TNF Europe and instead of seriously listening to my concerns, they simply told me that I was (supposedly) 'the first person to ever mention it as a possible problem', and consequently would 'pass on my concerns' but it was abundantly clear that they thereafter considered my interaction with them redundant and satisfactorily concluded. In short, buyer beware: TNF appear to have something of an 'attitude problem' - instead of properly considering customer feedback, they apparently seek to diminish its credibility and continue to produce products with known flaws. TNF have achieved a huge growth in market share partly because they have focused upon satisfying the demands of the fashion industry, to appeal to a broader cross-section of the general public. Their design teams are therefore unfortunately focused as much on 'form OVER function' as they are on 'form FOLLOWS function'. I had hoped that, on account of this particular jacket being marketed as part of the 'Summit Series', the design team might have biased their focus in favour of 'form FOLLOWS function', but my experience has sadly proved otherwise.

In conclusion, this IS a nice, lightweight, goodlooking jacket which is great for doing the shopping on a winters day, but please don't believe the nonsense marketing hype that it's designed for serious mountaineering use (or on any day when there's more than a slight breeze). If you like it, then by all means buy it but bear in mind that you will still need to buy a more serious jacket in addition, for those days when you want to go somewhere more demanding than the high street or the shopping mall.

If TNF decide to swallow their pride and modify the design of this hood for Winter 2010, they will at least triple the usability of this jacket so please bear this in mind if you read this review in 2010 or beyond. This jacket has potential for fast, lightweight ascents but ONLY IF the hood design is improved to protect the neck and chin.

The views expressed above are mine, not those of BackCountry :-)

View Details: The North Face Prism Optimus Down Jacket - Men's

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No