Should a new pair of Dansko's be very snug ( almost uncomfortable) or slightly loose? For me this is the difference of one shoe size.

I like Amanda Roper's sizing tips. I do not think they should be snug -- particulary if they are "almost uncomfortable." A little snug by the metatarsals is okay, because that area of the clog will stretch. The clog should not be snug at the heel.

Here are a few guidelines to remember when deciding if the clog fits your foot: * heel should move up and down freely * fit may be snug when stepping into the clog * toes should wiggle freely * should be able to fit your little finger behind your heel

Yes, the Dankso Clog should be pretty snug when you buy them - they need breaking in fer sure. I wore 2 pairs of socks to break them in around the house. It takes time for fer sure worth it for the years to come.

Hey Robin, I got my wife a pair of these and the first pair were just a little loose. They stretched and ended up being too big. We went 1 size down and once they had stretched out they were perfect. In my opinion I'd got with the smaller of the two and if they end up not working out you can always return them and get the next size up. Hope that helps.