Clothing

Gear

Accessories

Gear Question

MSR WindPro Stove

Item #CAS0372 | 13 in Stock

What is the difference between this stove and the MSR SimmerLite...

By Ranked #333 - Canister Stoves June 9, 2009

What is the difference between this stove and the MSR SimmerLite Stove? I see that they use different types of fuel... Why choose one over the other?

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

By Ranked #44 - Canister Stoves December 18, 2009

The biggest issue I have with liquid stoves: no simmer. Even if they say they simmer in the specs, they don't. Anything other than boiling water/melting snow is a pain.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

By Ranked #142 - Canister Stoves December 10, 2009

This question is "What is the difference between pressurized fuel stoves (Aka "canister") and liquid fuel stoves?" Canisters (like the WindPro) are gas under pressure. Liquid fuel stoves (like the Simmerlite) attach to an empty bottle that you fill the fuel with yourself. Here are some benefits of each: PRESSURIZED FUEL/CANISTER STOVES (Ex. WindPro) - Stoves themselves are generally cheaper (= cost up front) - Because the fuel is under pressure the gas already comes out as a vapor and is ready to safely burn, so you don't have to prime it, which can be tricky for beginners and is an extra step (= ease of use, quicker to food) - Because the canister is already under pressure, you do not have to pressurize it yourself by hand (= ease of use) - Because you don't have to prime the stove, you will not get black soot all over you or your stove (= cleaner) - Because you don't have to manually pressurize the canister, it is more uniform the flame can be adjusted MUCH more than that of liquid fuel for simmering things. (= more cooking versatility) - If you are going out for trips that you cook less than 7 times, the overall weight (stove + fuel needed) is less than most liquid fuel stoves, including the Simmerlite. (= lightweight) BENEFITS OF LIQUID FUEL STOVES (Ex. SimmerLite) - Fuel is cheaper (= cost in the long run) - White gas is easier to find outside of the U.S. (and you can't travel with fuel) (= more versitile if traveling) - Because you can open the fuel bottle, you always know exactly how much fuel you have and you can bring only what you need rather than one full and one partly empty canister (= peace of mind, possibly light weight) - Because you fill the bottle on your own, you do not have to dispose of, or try to recycle (sometimes difficult) the empty canister (= can be more eco-friendly) - Because you buy your own fuel bottles, you can attach different sizes for different trips and carry only the amount of fuel you need (= can be lighter) - If you are going out for trips that you cook more than 7 times (or you need to boil snow for water), the overall weight (stove + fuel needed) is less than most pressurized fuel stoves, including the WindPro. (= lightweight, more efficient) - Liquid fuel stoves perform MUCH better under cold (below 30) and high-altitude conditions (above 11,000). If you are going to be somewhere freezing AND high altitude much of the time, it is a much better choice. (= more versatile) There are some exceptions to the rules and some tricks you can do to improve certain aspects of them, but these are the basics, and the difference comes down to what YOU will be using it for.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

By Ranked #6 - Canister Stoves June 9, 2009

A few things the Simmer light is heavier but has about a min faster boil time. Different fuels and the Windpro has a Heat Reflector and a Windscreen where the simmerLite does not. Also the SimmerLite is just stainless steel. Hope that helps

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

Tech Specs:

Material:
Stainless steel, aluminum 
Fuel Type:
MSR IsoPro 
Burn Time:
90min [8oz canister] 
Boil Time:
4.25min 
Simmer:
Yes 
Auto Ignition:
No 
Windscreen:
Yes 
Heat Reflector:
Yes 
Parts Kit:
No 
Cleaning Tool:
Shaker jet technology 
Stuff Sack:
Yes 
Hard Case:
No 
Size:
[Closed] 4 x 3.5 x 3.5in ( 10 x 8.8 x 8.8cm) 
Weight:
6.8oz (193g) 
Recommended Use:
Backpacking, camping, cooking 
Manufacturer Warranty:
Lifetime 
Country of Origin:
China 
Close This Window

Change me.