- Home
- Kelty Tioga Backpack - 5000-5500cu in
- Question and Answer
- Kelty Tioga Backpack - 5000-5500cu in
Gear Question
what backpack is more compfortable an external frame pack or...
By Garrett Perkins
Ranked #1032 - Backpacks
June 8, 2009
what backpack is more compfortable an external frame pack or an internel
View Details: Kelty Tioga Backpack - 5000-5500cu in
By Jeff Gerhard
Ranked #1 - Backpacks
September 25, 2009
This is totally a matter of preference. After starting with a Kelty external frame pack years ago, I have been using an internal frame pack since 1988. I like the freedom of movement especially when bushwhacking in tight places & packing into high camps above timberline. This type of pack actually feels like an extension of my back, affording me better balance without having to make corrections as a result of being side or top heavy. I also like the way all my gear fits inside giving it a cleaner look & nothing to snag tree branches, etc. I haven't had to use external accessory straps since then.
Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No
By Raivyn
Ranked #310 - Backpacks
September 22, 2009
Re: Comfort - Internal vs. External Internal frames: sit closer to your body and generally are taller and slimmer = not likely to get caught on branches = easier to move around. External frames: sit on an frame so there is some separation between the pack and your back = your back won't get as hot and sweaty as with an internal frame pack. External frames: for their capacity are usually much lighter than an internal frame pack with similar capacity (sometimes as much as a pound) = lighter pack is going to be more comfortable over longer distances. Note: An internal frame with back venting features (i.e. mesh) are going to be more ultralight (= less durable) and the capacity will be less than an external frame with comparable weight.
Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No
By Chris Wynja
Ranked #20 - Backpacks
June 9, 2009
It really depends on the type of load you are carrying and where you are carrying it. External frame packs are load warriors: packs designed to carry large loads for long distances over relatively well established trails without a lot of low overhanging branches or narrow passages. An internal frame pack is ideally suited for trips where balance is critical or where narrow spaces will be encountered.
Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No
By Andrew
Ranked #2056 - Backpacks
June 8, 2009
I have found internal ones to be more comfortable.
Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No
Tech Specs:
- Material:
- 600D Polyester ripstop
- Volume:
- 5000cu in (82L); 5500cu in (90L)
- Suspension:
- External aluminum frame
- Hydration Compatible:
- Yes
- Torso Adjustment:
- Yes
- Detachable Pack:
- No
- Sleeping Bag Compartment:
- Yes
- Rain Cover:
- No
- Access Types:
- Top
- Pockets:
- [External] 2 zippered side, 1 front, 1 water bottle; [Internal] 1 hydration
- Snowboard Carry:
- No
- Ski Carry:
- No
- Ice Axe Loops:
- 1
- Shovel Pocket:
- No
- Weight:
- [5000] 5lb 9oz (2.5kg); [5500] 5lb 10oz (2.5kg)
- Recommended Use:
- Backpacking
- Manufacturer Warranty:
- Lifetime
Change me.


