Clothing

Gear

Accessories

Get Your Profile Dialed

Ian McCalder

Climber // Camper/Hiker // Skier

Ian McCalder: #42 of 91,688 Top 100 Gear Guru More Information

9 Reviews:

Helpful?
12 Yes | 0 No

9 Questions:

Helpful?
1 Yes | 0 No

102 Answers:

Helpful?
31 Yes | 4 No

6 Photos:

Helpful?
4 Yes | 1 No

3 Comments:

Helpful?
0 Yes | 0 No

0 Gearlists:

Helpful?
0 Yes | 0 No

  • Stomping Grounds:

    I love the Canadian Rockies!
  • Bio:

    I'm an avid climber. It's the activity that drives me to be outdoors. Camping and hiking are just ways to get to the crag for me.

    Skiing is another weakness of mine and keeps me busy in the winter. I'm dabbling in ice climbing, and feel confident I'll end up an ice junkie in a couple years.

Flag

Un-Flag

Close

Something wrong with this profile?

Thanks for pointing it out. We'll take it down immediately and send it to our clean-up crew.

This profile was: (Optional)

Use your real name to add some legitimacy to your content. Real names mean real community, and real community means real knowledge. Gear Gurus who use their real names get bumped up 1.5x for each contribution - you deserve the credit. For more info check out the Help Center.

This is how you compare to all the other Gear Gurus on Backcountry.com. You earn one point for each list / review / question / answer / gear photo / comments / votes you contribute. You gain an extra point every time someone gives one of your contributions a thumbs up, but you lose a point for every thumbs down. Bonus: if you use your real name, your point total increases by 1.5x—you deserve credit for putting your neck on the line to make this community better. For more info, check out the Help Center.

Change me.

This is how you compare to the other Gear Gurus within a group of products. You earn one point for each of your list / reviews / questions / answers / photos / comments / votes. You gain an extra point every time someone gives one of your contributions a thumbs up (killer), but you lose a point for every thumbs down (filler). Bonus: if you use your real name, your point total increases by 1.5x-you deserve credit for putting your neck on the line to make this community better. For more info, check out the Help Center.

Rocking the Phantom 0 in Iceland.

Rocking the Phantom 0 in Iceland.

Mountain Hardwear Phantom Sleeping Bag: 0 Degree Down

August 31, 2009

In the interior of Iceland it gets cold at night. The Phantom 0 was so ridiculously warm I was tempted to spend my trip like this instead of hiking. Fortunately, I didn't give in to temptation.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

0 Comments

View Product Details >
See all photos for this product >

Dragonfly in Iceland

Dragonfly in Iceland

MSR DragonFly Stove

June 23, 2009

Cooked up some nice vegetarian chili using the Dragonfly at Landmannalaugar, Iceland.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

0 Comments

View Product Details >
See all photos for this product >

Minibus 23 in Iceland

Minibus 23 in Iceland

The North Face Minibus 23 Tent 2-Person 3-Season

June 23, 2009

The vestibules were more than big enough to hold all our stuff.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

0 Comments

View Product Details >
See all photos for this product >

Minibus 23 in Iceland

Minibus 23 in Iceland

The North Face Minibus 23 Tent 2-Person 3-Season

June 23, 2009

Rocking the Minibus in Landmannalaugar.

Helpful Votes: 2 Yes | 0 No

0 Comments

View Product Details >
See all photos for this product >

Ice Climbing in Tremor pants

Ice Climbing in Tremor pants

Outdoor Research Tremor Softshell Pant - Men's

February 3, 2009

Aside from a couple crampon-induced holes, these pants worked perfectly for an ice climbing session on a frigid weekend in January.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 1 No

0 Comments

View Product Details >
See all photos for this product >

Ice Climbing in Mentor

Ice Climbing in Mentor

Outdoor Research Mentor Jacket - Men's

February 3, 2009

Took the Mentor ice climbing on a very cold January weekend. It performed fantastically.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

0 Comments

Sold Out

MontBell Thunderhead Pants - Men's

1 day ago

Hey James, the knees are lined with Paclite, but the rest of the pants are made of Gore-Tex Pro Shell. See the listing on Montbell's website here:
http://www.montbell.us/products/disp.php?cat_id=60&p_id=2328492

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Metropolis Parka - Women's

1 day ago

Hey Kat. Altering technical outerwear is tricky business. You need to find a truly brave tailor that is willing to tackle a down jacket. If there is a place near you that does custom down work they might be willing to touch it, but your average "Jim's Alterations" in the mall won't go anywhere near it. My advice would be to return the jacket to Backcountry and exchange it for something that fits you better. Mountain Hardwear makes a Downtown Coat that is very similar to this one that you might like, and tends to fit a bit shorter. Hope that helps.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Mountain Hardwear Stance Pant - Men's

3 days ago

Well Backcountry obviously doesn't have it. Try some of the other retailors listed here: http://www.mountainhardwear.com/WhereToBuy.aspx?jdeStyleId=OM3155&top=1827&cat=1870&prod=3516&isGeneric=false

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Patagonia Friction Belt

3 days ago

Heh..."sans". Awesome.

I would try any camping store in your area, or any shop with a gear repair department. I know here we have a decent shop that does second hand gear and repairs, so you may want to see if there's something like that near you. Failing that give your local REI a call and see if they can just send you one. I think the closest one to you will be in Mass. though.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Outdoor Research Mentor Jacket - Men's

4 days ago

I have the Mentor as well in a medium and it does fit a little larger. I'm 2" taller than you, so it fits me well for winter activities. You're bang on when you say it's meant to allow layering. OR cuts their shells a little bigger for that very reason. If it doesn't fit, just exchange it for a small. Backcountry.com has a fantastic return/exchange policy.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Columbia Tiger Eye Down Jacket - Women's

4 days ago

Nancy that's going to happen with any down jacket, especially new ones. During construction of the jacket some of the down gets trapped, usually in seams, and eventually works its way to the surface. There really isn't anything you can do to "seal" the jacket short of covering the entire inside with duct tape. If you're just leaking a few feathers, then I wouldn't worry about it. However if you suddenly empty a baffle then it's time to head back to the store and warranty the jacket.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

Permanently Out of Stock -- View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Mountain Hardwear Alchemy Softshell Jacket - Men's

5 days ago

Hey there Ely. Welcome to the world of softshells, my favorite type of jackets. You won't be disappointed. Here are my thoughts on those three jackets.

The TNF Apex Bionic is a solid softshell. It's a no-thrills package that is windproof, water resistant and decently warm. It'll breathe fairly well, but it's boring. Every 19 year old kid in the mountains has one.

The Marmot Ultima is kind of interesting. I like the carbon from coconut fabric for natural odor protection. However I think you'll find it a little on the chilly side, especially when you're just standing around. If you're a naturally warm person though, this might be a good investment.

The Alchemy is lined with Gore Windstopper which makes it totally windproof, but also highly water resistant. The Apex Bionic is also windproof and water resistant, but the pockets are too darn low to get in when I'm wearing a harness or backpack hip belt. If you plan on wearing a pack at all I would suggest going for the Alchemy since the pockets are placed high enough to get at when your pack hip belt is doing its job. The MHW Alchemy is my favorite of the three, and that's mostly due to the pocket placement.

Also, the Alchemy will have a very athletic fit to it. The medium for you will be perfect. TNF fits a little boxier, so depending on how much room you want sizing down to the small might be a good idea. I'm the same size as you, just 10 lbs heavier, and the small Bionic fit nicely. There wasn't much room underneath, but sometimes that's okay. I'm not sure what the sizing is like on the Ultima, but I do know Marmot tends to fit rather "athletically". Therefore you should probably try a medium in that one too.

Hope that helps.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Scarpa SL M3 Backpacking Boots - Men's

6 days ago

I would contact Scarpa directly Garrett. They can either find a vendor for you, or potentially sell you laces directly. Give them a call at 303.998.2895.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Cloudveil Firsturn Softshell Jacket - Men's

October 29, 2009

Jon, that depends entirely on what you're using the jacket for. If I'm just walking from the house to the car, and from the car to the office, then replacing my nylon rain jacket with a Gore-Tex shell really isn't worth it. However, if I'm ski touring, ice climbing, and in heavy rain a lot then the nylon jacket is bound to get shredded where a sturdier shell (soft or hard, some softshells are pretty weatherproof these days) would stand strong.

If you can't rationalize upgrading chances are you don't need to. As long as your jackets keep you warm, dry, and safe when they need to, there's no point in blowing money on something that's newer and shinier. That is, of course, in my opinion.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Mountain Hardwear Kramer Softshell Jacket - Men's

October 29, 2009

Hey Joe. The Kramer itself is not overly warm I would recommend layering with it. If you like Mountain Hardwear the Monkey Man Fleece is pretty kick-ass to layer with. I have last year's model and it's super warm. Also the Nitrous Jacket is a very nice down-insulated layering piece. If you want to look outside Mountain Hardwear, there's another down piece by Outdoor Research called the Transcendent Sweater which I own and really like. I would also suggest you look at the Repoint Jacket by North Face. It's a synthetically insulated jacket which will also layer nicely. Hope that helps.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Scarpa Summit GTX Mountaineering Boot - Men's

October 27, 2009

The Summits are definitely warmer. I'm actually wearing them right now and my feet are toasty.

The Summits are a much more "hardcore" mountaineering boot than the Charmoz too. If you're looking to tackle vertical ice, I would highly recommend the Summits over the Charmoz.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Scarpa Summit GTX Mountaineering Boot - Men's

October 27, 2009

Yes they do. I'm wearing them right now and can see the little tab you'd pull out to fit the GSB spike in.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Mountain Hardwear Kramer Softshell Jacket - Men's

October 26, 2009

Hey Joe. The Kramer has a few benefits over a Gore-Tex shell. The Kramer has a bit of insulation on the upper arms and shoulders in the form of flat-back Monkey Phur. It helps to hold the warmer air on your shoulders a little bit better than a typical shell would. There is also a body-mapped micro fleece backer on the jacket which provides extra breathability under the arms but provide a little but of heat retention across the back.

Insulation aside the only other benefits the Kramer has stem from it's ski/snowboard centric design. If you're not going to use it for skiing or boarding, then there are better jackets out there. Simply put, the removable snow skirt, goggle pocket, lift pass holder, and oodles of pockets are suited best for spending a day on the hill.

I have the Kramer and a Gore-Tex shell. For skiing, the Kramer is sweet. It's my fair weather ski shell, since I find it fits a little slimmer than most ski shells. The breathability can't be beat. In my opinion MHW makes some of the most breathable proprietary alternatives to Gore-Tex. That being said, this jacket is not for activities such as ice climbing. That's where the Gore-Tex shell proves its worth. Alpine pockets, unbeatable waterproofing, super hardy face fabrics, and a fit that you can seriously layer under make my hardshell my best friend with heading outside at -25 C.

So to answer your question in short. The Kramer is better for skiing, in my opinion, than typical hardshells. However, keep it on the hill. It has a few shortcomings when adapting to other activities.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Mountain Hardwear Torsion Glove

October 23, 2009

Hey BZ. This glove is not waterproof. MHW is using either Conduit or OutDry in all their waterproof gloves this winter. So unless you see either of those technologies on the glove, it isn't waterproof.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Sentinel Thermal Softshell Jacket - Men's

October 22, 2009

Yo Rjg. I have the black Sentinel and it has accompanied me on a few rock trips. The black isn't too bad with chalk. I would probably throw it in the wash with some Tech Wash after a weekend of climbing though since the chalk is going to gum up the breathability of the fabric. Abrasion-wise this thing is tough as nails. Mine has stood up to a year of abuse and is almost in tip-top condition. I would suggest keeping the jacket away from fires. *grumble* Lint-wise I've had no problems at all. Then again I don't have any pets either.

Helpful Votes: 2 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Apex Big Wall Softshell Pant - Men's

October 22, 2009

I would try it on Robert. It's pretty easy to guess jacket sizes, but pants are a little trickier.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Icebreaker BodyFit260 Tech Top - Long-Sleeve - Men's

October 21, 2009

Yo FNM. Icebreaker stuff used to be made in New Zealand. They got so big though that the operation out grew the manufacturing capacity in NZ, so they moved it all to China. All Icebreaker is now made in China, according to my rep.

You can actually check out the manufacturing process on the Icebreaker website. They've got a little video showing the factory it's made in, which is pretty cool. Hope that helps.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Outdoor Research Mithril Softshell Jacket - Men's

October 19, 2009

Hey there Rwuff. It's not a high pile lining like the Herculues. It's very similar to the lining in a TNF Apex Bionic; just there to keep out a bit of the cold, but not really enough to act as an insulating layer (depending on your climate).

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Norrøna Lyngen Softsthell Pant - Men's

October 17, 2009

They aren't technically "waterproof", rather "highly water resistant". Chances are they won't soak right though, but your mid-layer is likely to get damp. If you want to remain totally dry go for a full on Gore-Tex pant.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Mountain Hardwear Monkey Man Fleece Jacket - Men's

October 17, 2009

Yes! This year uses a very different fleece fabric. Last year the Monkey Man used MHW's proprietary Monkey Phur fleece. It's very soft, but mats like crazy. This year they've switched to a Polartec fabric that is much coarser (i.e. less soft) but will stand up to matting much better than last year's model. It's still warm, just not as "pettable" as the '08 model.

Helpful Votes: 2 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Outdoor Research Ferrosi Hooded Softshell Jacket - Women's

October 16, 2009

It's a pure shell. There is no insulation in the Ferrosi. This thing won't insulate you, but it will help to cut the wind. If you're looking for a warmer softshell check out the OR Mithril Stormshell.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Mountain Hardwear Lamina 35 Sleeping Bag: 35 Degree Synthetic

October 16, 2009

Okay, here's the rule of thumb I used when selling MHW sleeping bags. If you are:
5' 6" and shorter - use a short.
5' 7" to 6' - use a regular.
taller than 6' - Use a long.

This method has yet to fail me, and I stick to it when I buy myself sleeping bags.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Mountain Hardwear Dragon Softshell Jacket - Men's

October 14, 2009

How does this differ from the spring 2009 version? The MHW webpage says this jacket is "new" even though it's been around for a year already.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Mountain Hardwear Quark Jacket - Men's

October 14, 2009

Hey Josh. This rain shell is indeed cut large enough to fit a midlayer underneath. The face fabric also has a nice stretch to it as well, so your movement won't be restricted when layering up.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

Sold Out

Outdoor Research Motto Jacket - Men's

October 14, 2009

Well, aside frome being half the price of the Stingray, the Motto is also not a Gore-Tex shell. Instead it uses Outdoor Research's own waterproof membrane called Ventia. After that we just get in to little details such as pocket placement, the ability to remove the powder skirt/hood (in the Motto), and colour.

I have quite a few OR pieces and have been very happy with them to date. I would fully recommend OR over Arc'teryx in this case simply for the money it will save you.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

Sold Out

MontBell Ultralight Down Inner Jacket - Men's

October 13, 2009

Hey Bev. Throw that thing in the washer with some Nikwax Down Wash and you'll be smoke scent free. Afterwards, chuck it in the dryer with some tennis balls to break up the down clumps and you'll be good as new.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Outdoor Research Furio Jacket - Men's

October 12, 2009

Hey Justin. OR cuts their shells a little on the bigger side. I'm a medium pretty much across the board, and I have the Mentor in a medium. It's roomy enough to fit some layers underneath for sure. I would suggest buying whatever size you generally are in your jackets. Keep in mind that Backcountry also offers a 30 day satisfaction guarantee, so if it doesn't fit you have a month to exchange it for the next size up.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

Sold Out

Outdoor Research Ferrosi Hooded Softshell Jacket - Women's

October 12, 2009

Hey Andrea. The pockets are not accessible whilst wearing a harness/pack, unfortunately. That being said this hoodie has enough redeeming qualities that I will heartily recommend it. It's likely my favorite garment from OR.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Amp Hybrid Jacket - Men's

October 10, 2009

Mmmm...I don't think so Allen. There's no insulation on this jacket, so you'd be pretty chilly. If you're looking for a warm softshell, check out the North Face Apex Bionic Thermal.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

Sold Out

The North Face Cipher Windstopper Jacket - Men's

October 8, 2009

Go for the Apex Bionic Ryan. It's easier on the wallet and fleece lined. The Cipher has no fleece, thus very little heat retaining ability. Also, the Apex Aerobic material on the Cipher will vent heat like crazy. The Bionic is made of the much thicker Apex Climate Bloc material.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

Permanently Out of Stock -- View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

66 North Iceland Stormur Jacket - Men's

October 7, 2009

Hi Amy, I just checked the tag on my Vatnajokull Fleece Jacket and it was, in fact, made in Latvia. My understanding is that 66 North Iceland garments are not made in Europe, but they are designed in Iceland. I'm quite happy with mine and would stand behind any product they make.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

Permanently Out of Stock -- View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Mountain Hardwear Alchemy Softshell Jacket - Men's

October 6, 2009

Oh these are my favorite questions to answer. Here goes:

Let's start with a comparison of the Alchemy and the Nemesis. Overall, the Alchemy is a heavier, thus warmer, jacket vs the Nemesis. Furthermore the biggest, most important difference is how these jackets stack up against the wind. The Alchemy jacket is windproof due to the inclusion of a Gore Windstopper laminate. The Nemesis is not windproof, only wind resistant. Lastly, the Alchemy has alpine style pocket on it which will allow you access to them when wearing a pack, harness, whatever.

Which one is better depends on what you'll be using them for. For me, the Alchemy is a better jacket since I tend to avoid aerobic activities in favour of alpine slogs through nasty weather (i.e. bone chilling wind). You also mention you like a stiffer face fabric; the Nemesis is a much softer, and stretchier fabric than the Alchemy jacket. They are both covered by MHW's lifetime warranty, so you don't really need to worry about defective products.

Now then, let's compare the Alchemy (since I feel it to be the better jacket) and the Apex Bionic. These jackets are very similar. Both are windproof, both are sofshells, both are fleece lined. However the Alchemy is more expensive since it uses licensed technology (that being the Gore Windstopper). Again, in my opinion, the Apex Bionic is the better jacket for all round and city use but that's soley based on the price. If you're going to throw on your hiking books and scramble up somthing this weekend, then I would suggest the Alchemy. It'll stand up better to abuse and it has the higher set pockets. Those pockets really seal the deal for me since I spend a lot of my time outdoors in a harness.

One further note, if you haven't looked at the Outdoor Research Mithril Softshell, do that too. It's water/wind proof, has a hood, and is a fair stiff/beefy face fabric. I like it a lot, except the pocket placement.

Helpful Votes: 2 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Columbia Crag Mountain II Softshell Jacket - Men's

October 6, 2009

Hey Eman. I've tried out both the Crag Mountain II and the Ascender. In my opinion the Crag Mountain is far and beyond a better jacket. It cuts wind, sheds water, and fits much better than the Ascender jacket. I would whole heartedly recommend the Crag Mountain over the Ascender. If you're looking for something even beefier, check out the Columbia Ice Ax II Softshell.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

Sold Out

The North Face Apex Bionic Jacket - Men's

October 5, 2009

Yeah, that's the only difference Matt. TNF hasn't touched this jacket much in the last couple years. It's done so well for them that all they need to do now is change the colour of the zipper pulls every season.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Apex Elixir Softshell Pant - Men's

September 28, 2009

I found the Talus pants surprisingly unstretchy. I would suggest the North Face pants, I have a pair, and they are incredibly comfortable.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

Sold Out

Norrøna Lyngen Softsthell Pant - Men's

September 28, 2009

Do these bad boys have a fleece liner in them at all?

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Outdoor Research Trio Jacket - Men's

September 25, 2009

Those are some pretty brutal conditions you're looking at DWJ. I'd look at something a little more hearty than the Trio jacket. Personally, I prefer to layer my jackets for my mountain excursions. Usually I'll put a light fleece under my OR Transcendent Sweater (down insulated) and then my OR Mentor Jacket (Gore-Tex) on top. I would suggest going that route as the insultion on most 3 in 1 jackets is "medium warmth" at best.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Apex Bionic Jacket - Men's

September 25, 2009

I would favour the Leadville Jsung. It's cut as a running jacket, and the Apex Bionic is not. Whilst I like the TNF jacket as a generalist, the Leadville is really designed as a running jacket. Since that's what it sounds like you'll be using it for, I would suggest buying the tool designed for the job. The Leadville won't be as warm as the Bionic, so you might need a decent base layer (see: Icebreaker) to put underneath it.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Interceptor Jacket - Men's

September 25, 2009

Hey Nicolas. North Face has a pretty standard "box" fit to their core clothing line. You'll find their Summit and Flight Series have more athletic fits. Since this jacket does not belong to the Summit or Flight Series, I would say it has a pretty standard, perhaps "relaxed" even, fit to it. Also, I have no idea what an "authentic" fit is, so I suppose it could be that too.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

Sold Out

The North Face Valkyrie Softshell Jacket - Men's

September 25, 2009

Yeah, that's what I was afraid of. Can TNF please just put a hood on the Valhalla jacket? I would buy that thing in a heartbeat if had a helmet compatable hood.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

Sold Out

Mountain Hardwear Chockstone Softshell Jacket - Men's

September 24, 2009

Hi Nicolas,

The material certainly is a softshell. It's a lightweight softshell meant to protect you from light rain and moderate winds. Since there is no liner in the jacket the material will be very stretchy. I quite like Mountain Hardwear's softshell fabric and think you'll be quite happy with this jacket.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Valkyrie Softshell Jacket - Men's

September 23, 2009

Are the pockets actually high enough to get into whilst wearing a harness? They don't look any different than the pockets on the Sentinel, and those aren't accessibile whilst harnessed.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

Sold Out

Outdoor Research Mithril Softshell Jacket - Men's

September 22, 2009

Hey kbuzz. I've tried this bad boy on and the hood is a little small for use with a helmet. You'd be better off cramming the hood under your helmet.

There is no powder skirt, and I found the jacket to be cut a little on the short side. It's a fantastic jacket, but it sounds to me like you're looking for a ski shell. This isn't really designed for skiing. Check out the MHW Kramer too. It's rad.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Outdoor Research Latitude Mitten

September 22, 2009

Nope, not even close. The Cornice uses a Gore-Tex shell whilst the Alti Mitt uses a Ventia (sill waterproof) shell. There are also cosmetic difference in the way the wrist cinches down and the like.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Outdoor Research Furio Jacket - Men's

September 22, 2009

Adm this is the jacket you've been looking for. The entire face fabric is 70D ripstop nylon that can be dragged across rocks, trees, and probably hot pokers without a problem. It's guaranteed waterproof by Gore-Tex and backed up by a lifetime warranty from OR. The Paclite and Pro shells are both wonderfully breathable. I have nothing bad to say about this jacket. If I didn't already have a shell, I promise you I'd have one in my closet.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

Sold Out

Mountain Hardwear Typhoon Jacket - Men's

September 22, 2009

Nope, no zip in compatibility here I'm afraid. This is just a straight up shell jacket that's meant to sit on top of your fleece.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Mountain Hardwear Downhill Down Parka - Men's

September 11, 2009

Hi Jsung. The Conduit laminate is windproof as well as waterproof. This jacket will keep you dry and super warm. Actually, now that I'm looking at it this is a damn cool jacket. Hmmm...Christmas is coming...

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

Sold Out

Marmot Afterburner Fleece Jacket - Men's

September 2, 2009

Jules, you can wear whatever shell you want on top of this. If you're doing something active and you don't require total storm protection, then grab a nice softshell to layer over top. If you want to stick with Marmot, I'm a big fan of the Kingpin jacket. If you're looking for a higher degree of weatherproofing, then pick up a nice hardshell. Anything with Gore-Tex in it will keep you dry and cut the wind. It all depends on what you plan to do whilst wearing this fleece.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Scarpa Triolet GTX Mountaineering Boot - Men's

September 2, 2009

How does this boot compare to the Scarpa Freney XT GTX? I'm looking for something I can use mostly for ice climbing, but likely some alpine climbing as well and am wondering which boot would be better suited.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Apex Pneumatic Jacket - Men's

August 31, 2009

The two jackets are also made of different materials. The Pneumatic is made of Apex Aerobic which is a very light weight and breathable softshell. It's air permeable so it will be wind resistant. The Apex Bionic is made of Apex ClimateBlock. It's a much heavier softshell material that is rated to 0 CFM for air permeability. This means it is essentially windproof.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

Sold Out

The North Face Apex Pneumatic Jacket - Men's

August 31, 2009

The Nimble and the Pneumatic are essentially the same thing. They are both made of Apex Aerobic softshell with a DWR coating. I'm a fan of pockets, so I'd go for the Pneumatic myself.

Also, I'm the same height as you, but about 8 pounds heavier and I fit a small fairly well. TNF tends to have a rather boxy cut in their standard line of clothing, so I'd suggest you take a small as well.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

Sold Out

The North Face Thunder Down Jacket - Men's

August 31, 2009

Hey Anon. Check out the Transcendent Sweater by Outdoor Research, the Nitrous Jacket by Mountain Hardwear or the Patagonia Down Sweater. You'll likely find the Outdoor Research or Patagonia jacket fits the longest and MHW tends to cut puffy jackets short to fit above a climbing harness.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Jannu GTX Hiking Boot - Men's

August 31, 2009

Hi mhare. This boot works well as a stiff hiking boot suitable for multi-day excursions with a heavy pack. Yes, it has a full nylon shank, but it won't take clip-on crampons that you need for highly technical terrain. If you're looking for something to take you vertically (i.e. ice climbing) check out a true mountaineering boot by Scarpa or La Sportiva.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Scarpa Freney XT GTX Mountaineering Boots - Men's

August 27, 2009

How does this boot compare to the Scarpa Triolet GTX? I'm looking for something I can use mostly for ice climbing, but likely some alpine climbing as well and am wondering which boot would be better suited.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Salomon Evo Softshell Jacket - Men's

August 17, 2009

By "skying" I'm going to assume you mean "skiing". The answer is yes, this will work well for skiing in Vermont. It does have some measure of insulation, but I would use it more as a moderate/fair weather ski shell. If you layered up underneather with some down insulation it might even hold out in the -10 F temperature ranges.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Magnus Softshell Jacket - Men's

August 12, 2009

The North Face website says this jacket as an "alpine fit". What exactly does that mean? Is it the same as an "athletic fit"?

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

A little disappointing

Mountain Hardwear Dragon Softshell Jacket - Men's

Rating for this product: 3 August 11, 2009

Let me start by saying that this is a great jacket. It simply wasn't what I was looking for, nor did it meet my expectations. Hence the mediocre review.

I shall start with the perks, as there are many worthy of mention. First off, the Dragon is exceptionally light. The material itself is thin, yet appears to be strong. I have yet to damage it after battling several rocks, trees, bushes, and their ilk. Those of you concerned about weight savings will be pleasantly surprised. Secondly, I have a soft spot for thumbloops. I'm not entirely sure why, but this jacket got bonus points for having them. Third, the does indeed have a very nice stretch to it making sleeve ride-up rare. Lastly, it holds up fairly decent in the rain. Whilst camping in Iceland this was my rain shell. After a couple hours it did soak through, but I was merely "damp" as opposed to "wet" underneath. For the record though, take Gore-Tex to Iceland.

Now then, my general disappointment with the Dragon stems from a few things. Keep in mind that my criteria for a jacket was a totally windproof softshell with high, "alpine style", front pockets and a hood. Can someone please explain to me how I'm supposed to get into the hand pockets when wearing my climbing harness? When I first got the jacket it was conveniently very windy all week. I thought this would be a great way to test out what I thought was a Windstopper softshell. It became apparently immediately that this jacket, on its own, was ill-suited to retaining warmth. The wind whisked away my body heat instantly. The jacket I have is from spring 2009, and I think it is totally lined with Windstopper. In the new version for Fall 2009 only the hood and torso are lined; the arms and side panels are air-permeable which is great when you're layered up underneath and less great when in t-shirt mode. I also had some misgivings about the fit. I'm generally a medium in everything, but the medium in the Dragon feels big. I would hardly call it a "trim cut". This makes sense, to a degree, in the context of ice climbing with this jacket though as it allows a fleece to be layered under it.So there you have it.

I'm primarily disappointed because the jacket fits me wonky, lacks alpine pockets and frankly is too thin to retain body heat. I'm now eyeing up something to replace my Dragon likely from TNF or OR. As long as you don't mind the wind chilling your arms this jacket is awesome.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

2 Comments

Sold Out

The North Face Trajectory Hybrid Jacket - Women's

July 24, 2009

Hi Juls. The back of the jacket is not waterproof. It's meant to act more like a vent for heat and perspiration. If you're looking for a completely waterproof jacket try the North Face Venture jacket.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Outdoor Research Mithril Stormshell Jacket - Men's

July 23, 2009

Hey STE. This jacket uses a porous membrane, like Windstopper. However, unlike Windstopper, the membrane itself is waterproof. It's called Ventia and it is Outdoor Research's proprietary waterproof technology. There is also a DWR coating on the shell.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

Sold Out

The North Face Varius Guide Jacket - Men's

July 23, 2009

It's pretty unlikely that you'll be able to zip in your Monkey Man, Pat. Generally speaking different manufacturers use slightly different zippers just to avoid that situation. Last I checked Mountain Hardwear wasn't into making zip-in compatible coats, but that may change with their new Fall lineup. Keep an eye out.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

Sold Out

The North Face Apex Bionic Jacket - Men's

July 22, 2009

Nathan, I'm inclined to disagree with you on the point of the TNF jacket. Neither the Gamma LT, nor the Shift are windproof jackets. Perhaps I'm just a sucker for all things windproof (I'm wearing a Windstopper jacket as I type this), but I would buy the Apex Bionic before the Gamma LT or the Shift.

The Apex Bionic is made of Apex ClimateBlock which is rated at 0 CFM, thus it is windproof. Furthermore the Shift is horrendously expensive for a standard softshell. While I appreciate the fact that Backcountry is employing my countrymen by manufacturing the jacket in Canada, it's simply over-priced in my opinion. Likewise the Gamma LT is pricey, and still air-permeable.

While the North Face brand lacks the "hardcore" and "shiny" aspects that Arc'teryx and Backcountry carry, they still make a few solid pieces. The Apex Bionic is no exception, as it remains the standard to which other softshells are compared.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Khumbu Fleece Jacket - Men's

July 22, 2009

Hey Jay. There is no difference. It's all made of the same 200 weight traditional fleece. The "Charcoal Heather Grey" and "Charcoal Heather Grey/Charcoal Heather Grey" jacket even use the same photo. Regardless of which black configuration you buy, you'll get a black fleece jacket.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Atlantic Jacket - Women's

June 26, 2009

Hi Maha. You Manitobians are crazy. Here in Alberta it only gets to -40. You should join us for a balmy weekend in January some time.

The truth is that few jackets will keep you comfortable at -50, but lots of jackets will keep you alive. This one will definitely do the latter. With proper layering under the jacket and on your legs, you might even be able to shovel the driveway with this baby on. It is one of the warmest jackets TNF makes. My brother has the men's version and loves it. It kept him relatively warm when winter camping at -34.

The belt and hood are not removable, by the way.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

Permanently Out of Stock -- View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Arc'teryx Tau Pullover - Men's

June 24, 2009

Hey Nate. The Tau is cut slightly differently from the Accomplice. This has a more athletic (see: tighter) cut to act as a mid-layer. The Accomplice has a boxier cut to accommodate insulating layers underneath.

Both will serve well as a wind resistant mid-layer. I would also recommend the Vatnajokull fleece by 66 North Iceland. I just picked one up and love the thing. It's virtually wind proof, super warm, and cheaper than the Arc'teryx stuff (because it's on sale right now). Check it out: http://www.backcountryoutlet.com/outlet/SNI0123/66-North-Iceland-Vatnajokull-Jacket-Mens.html

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

Sold Out

Backcountry.com Shift Welder Hoody - Men's

June 24, 2009

For sure Mark. Nikwax and Grangers both make wash-in water repellancy for technical clothing. I would recommend Nikwax Softshell Proof. I just used it on my MHW Dragon jacket and it worked like a charm.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

This tent rules!

The North Face Minibus 23 Tent 2-Person 3-Season

The North Face Minibus 23 Tent 2-Person 3-Season

Rating for this product: 5 June 23, 2009

This tent is pretty much pure awesome. It's big enough that you don't have to intimately know your tent buddy to sleep two people comfortably. This was a HUGE concern for me, as I looked at a lot of Mountain Hardwear tents that claimed to be 2 person tents, but realistically only hold 1.5 people.

I've taken this tent to a few venues and it has performed admirably. It's easy enough to set up in the dark of Jasper National Park, and it's sturdy enough to stand up to 24 hours of rain and gusty winds in Landmannalaugar, Iceland. There was plenty of room for gear inside the vestibules, and even a little in the tent.

Technical details aside this tent is simply a joy to use. I highly recommend it. Also, the glow in the dark zipper pulls are just plain cool.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

0 Comments

View Product Details >
Read all Reviews about this product

The North Face Sentinel Thermal Softshell Jacket - Men's

June 8, 2009

Hi Jeremy. You'll find this thing pretty warm near the 70F mark, but from 50F to 65F you should be fine. It'll also depend on what you wear underneath. If you decide the fleece liner feels really nice against your bare flesh, you may opt to go shirtless under the Sentinel which would allow you to wear it in warmer climes. It also depends on what you're doing. If the Super Bowl is on and you're chilly in your house, then this will keep you warm if it's 70F outside. But if the mercury hits 70 and you want to go run a marathon, this will likely be too warm. This jacket is awesome. Buy, use it, love it. Regardless of the temperature.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Hero Triclimate Jacket - Men's

May 25, 2009

See Nick Bose's answer to the questions titled "How warm is it???" below.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Mountain Hardwear Monkey Man Fleece Zip T - Long-Sleeve - Men's

May 20, 2009

It's usually part of the Fall/Winter line-up from Mountain Hardwear, but I just checked the Fall '09 stuff and don't see it on the list. It appears as though it will be discontinued I'm afraid.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

Permanently Out of Stock -- View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Apex Bionic Jacket - Men's

May 14, 2009

The biggest difference is the country of origin. This jacket comes from China and the Shift originates in Canada. Still, I would agree with Cyrus. This jacket is sweet and differences are not worth $100.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Norrøna Falketind Gore-Tex Paclite Jacket - Men's

May 14, 2009

Hi Mike. I tried this jacket on a little while ago and it fits very slim. Through the body there was just enough room to get a base and mid layer. I did find the sleeves a little long, so depending on how "tall and lanky" you are they may fit you quite well. Just be aware that Norrona jackets tend to fit snugger through the shoulders and body.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Patagonia Capilene 2 Zip-Neck - Long-Sleeve - Men's

May 5, 2009

Hey Nan. First off, try using the live chat to get a real-time answer from the Backcountry staff. They are very knowledgable and can probably help you out.

Secondly, this might interest you: http://www.backcountry.com/store/MHW1168/Mountain-Hardwear-Wicked-Lite-T-Shirt-Long-Sleeve-Mens.html

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Oakley Argylotine Woven Shirt - Short-Sleeve - Men's

May 5, 2009

Hey Jpark. Use the "Chat Now" button in the upper right corner of the window to talk to a Backcountry employee. They will be able to answer questions regarding stock much faster than by posting it here.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 1 No

Permanently Out of Stock -- View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Icebreaker Beast Apollo Crew - Short-Sleeve - Men's

May 5, 2009

Hey Brandon,

The black and grey ones should be dark enough for single layer casual wear. I've got the grey one and I wouldn't call it translucent. The white-ish one (Bone I think) may prove to be problematic for you though. Go for a darker colour if you're concerned.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Mountain Hardwear Terra Jacket - Men's

May 4, 2009

Hi Matt,

I was talking to my Mountain Hardwear Rep a couple weeks ago about this jacket. According to him the Terra Jacket is actually MORE breathable than a Pro-Shell. Long term, the Pro Shell will be more waterproof though. Apparently the Terra fabric is the first proprietary waterproof/breathable that is more breathable than Gore-Tex. Hope that helps.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Sentinel Windstopper Soft Shell Jacket - Men's

May 1, 2009

Most any Summit Series piece from North Face is on the slimmer side. As far as softshells go this one isn't skin tight, but it won't accomodate a lot of bulk underneath unless you size up. I would say it's more of an athletic fit.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

Sold Out

Columbia Omni-Dry Mountain Tech T-Shirt - Short-Sleeve - Men's

May 1, 2009

Hey Josh. I poked around and couldn't find the weight of the shirt, even on Columbia's website. I would, however, suggest avoiding synthetic shirts unless you're going to have the opportunity to wash them. They will get smelly really fast. Might I suggest something made of Merino wool instead? Icebreaker in particular makes fantastic shirts that won't smell nearly as bad and are super light. Check 'em out.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Icebreaker BodyFit200 Oasis Crew - Men's

May 1, 2009

It's neither. The difference is age. BodyFit used to be called Skin. So the Skin clothing is just a little older. They fit, feel, and function the same though.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Icebreaker BodyFit200 Oasis Crew - Men's

May 1, 2009

Indeed. The number refers to the weight of the fabric in grams/meter². So a square meter of Bodyfit200 weighs 200 grams. Likewise the Bodyfit260 would weigh 260 grams. Basically the higher the number the heavier (i.e. warmer) the wool will be.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Pretty Decent

Petzl Adjama Harness - Men's

Petzl Adjama Harness - Men's

Rating for this product: 4 April 30, 2009

I'm a pretty big fan of this harness. I picked it up a year and a half ago and have been quite please with it thus far. Unlike a lot of other owners, I don't have problems with the sizing. Maybe it's just me.

The harness is fairly comfortable and only really begins to bite into my waist after three hours of routesetting. It's far from the lightest on the market, but I wouldn't describe it as bulky either. The four gear loops are nice in that you can carry up as much gear as you need. The speed buckles are awesome, and I'll never revert to double-backing again. All in all, it's a nice harness. Easy on the wallet and extremely versitile.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

0 Comments

View Product Details >
Read all Reviews about this product

The North Face Minibus 23 Tent 2-Person 3-Season

April 30, 2009

Why hello me. I would first like to thank those that tried to answer my question. However, since none of them actually own the tent in question, I will now answer my own question.

Yes, this is actually a two man tent. It is set up in my kitchen right now and it's easily the biggest two man tent I've ever seen. It can accomodate two Exped DownMat 7s with room to spare. There are plenty of pockets for gadgets and reading material. Once I have slept in it a few times outside my kitchen I'll throw up a review for it.

Hope that helps. Thank me.

Helpful Votes: 1 Yes | 1 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Apex Bionic Jacket - Men's

April 29, 2009

Hey Jonathan. I would suggest either setting your jacket on fire and getting a new one, or washing it with Nikwax Tech Wash. Granted, I haven't actually tried Tech Wash to get gasoline fumes out of my jackets, so I cannot gaurantee success. It's worth a shot though.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Thunder Jacket - Men's

April 29, 2009

Without having done a direct comparison (i.e. trying both on) I would say the Thunder. In my experience Primaloft (in the Red Point) is great stuff but cannot stand up to 800-fill down (in the Thunder). I have tried on the Red Point, and it was fairly warm. However I've tried on the OR version of the Thunder and it was fantastic even with a lower lofting down (650+). Go for the Thunder, you won't regret it.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

Sold Out

Columbia Thunderstorm II Jacket - Men's

April 29, 2009

Hey Adam,

I can't see any Velcro in the photos I'm afraid. However, every single jacket I've seen with Velcro on the hood has two strips of Velcro. One is usually on the outside of the hood located near the seam that joins the hood to the jacket. The other is likely inside the hood also near the jacket/hood seam. This allows one to roll the hood up and stow it in order to avoid having "floppy hood syndrom" whilst on the trail. Hope that helps.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

Permanently Out of Stock -- View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Valkyrie Softshell Jacket - Men's

April 16, 2009

Hey Brad,

I'm not sure which stripe or storm flaps you're referring to. Storm flaps traditionally cover the front zipper, and this jacket lacks those particular flaps. The only red I see on the grey jacket is from the zipper pulls and the inside lining of the cuffs. Does that help at all?

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

Sold Out

The North Face Opus Fleece Jacket - Men's

April 15, 2009

The Denali is actually a 300 weight fleece, but this is lighter than that. It'll be closer to the Khumbu Jacket by North Face.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

Permanently Out of Stock -- View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Norrøna Narvik Fleece Jacket - Men's

April 15, 2009

Yes. Norrona is sized small compared to North American sizings. I would suggest you buy a size up (large in this case) when ordering Norrona products.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Free Thinker II Jacket - Men's

April 15, 2009

Any heavy fleece jacket or down sweater will work just fine. Might I recommend The North Face Denali Jacket, The North Face Thunder Jacket, Mountain Hardwear Monkey Man Jacket, Outdoor Research Transcendent Sweater, and the Mountain Hardwear Nitrous Jacket.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

Permanently Out of Stock -- View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

The North Face Minibus 23 Tent 2-Person 3-Season

April 7, 2009

Actually a two man?

Hi, first off, thanks for the floor plan Angus. That will help out immensely. I'm just wondering if anyone has had a chance to see this thing in action. Most of my experience with tents has lead me to believe that a "3-man tent" is actually suitable for two people and a "2-man" is usually suitable for one person and a midget. So my question is this: Can you comfortably fit 2 people and some gear in the Minibus 23?

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Marmot Aegis Jacket - Men's

March 23, 2009

According to the Marmot website, this does indeed use the MemBrain Strata fabric.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Norrøna Lofoten Hybrid Soft Shell Jacket - Men's

March 13, 2009

Does anyone know how well this jacket stands up to the wind? I'm looking for a non-Arc'teryx softshell that could be used for climbing.

Helpful Votes: 0 Yes | 0 No

Permanently Out of Stock -- View Product Details >
Read all Q&A about this product >

Click to read all of Ian McCalder's contributions... Be patient. It might take a while.