Matthew W.wrote a review of Black Diamond Squall Tent 3-Person 4-Season on October 4, 2012
Familiarity: I've used it several times
Taking time to research a product usually pays off in the end. During my search for an affordable, light weight, four-season tent I found the BD Squall. Everything looks great on paper but after using this tent for two seasons I am very disappointed. Based on my experience with this product, here are some things you may want to consider.
1) This is a very large tent. Great for base camp but extremely hard to place if space is limited.
2) Two seasons of moderate use have resulted in the seam tape on the fly flaking off and sticking to the poles and tent body.
3) Poor design of the front tent flap causes a major stress point on the zipper which has failed twice since the purchase.
4) Not designed to withstand heavy winds even when guy-wires are emplloyed from the fly mounts.
Despite all these misgivings I still stand by BD as a company. I notified them about the poor quality of the fly and they are sending me a new one free of charge. Turns out they have had a few issues with the coating used on their flies in the past.
Take home point, take time to think about what you want out of the tent. Do you really need a three person? Are you going to be placing the tent on wide open ground or have to find space nestled between obstructions? If you are looking for a technical tent, this one probably isn't for you.