Got these for my son in Minneapolis. They are having a real winter and so they have had a great test drive! He says they are the cats meow for shovelling, snow blowing or snow sculpting! Fit is just right and the uninsulated version with just a pair of long underwear under is perfect for active use. Good so they don't drag in the snow or have gaps to let snow and cold in. He's @ 5'9" and thin and the regular is fine.