I like this jacket. It looks great, though it's just a little short (6-feet tall, 170#, size large). The arms are a decent length but my waist is not well shielded from the wind. Worse, TNF's Nuptse jacket has more down filling, is therefore warmer, is longer, and costs considerably less. But this looks better than the Nuptse and feels great to wear. I do wish the collar had more substance, as there's nothing between it and my hat to keep out the cold. But it looks great. Not sure I would wear it out in falling snow without a shell, despite the DWR claim.