Generally, I have been very happy with Marmot products but this one I had to return after a single use because it didn't work as expected.
The gloves fit right, look nice, have just the right thickness and would have been perfect for what I bought them for except they're not waterproof AT ALL. After a very short contact with snow they were soaking wet (I could actually wring water from them). They were not much different from a pair of fleece gloves that I used before and was trying to replace with Marmot Spring Gloves because they were getting wet. I have to continue my search for a relatively thin glove that I could use in the snow and don't get it wet...
This is my first wool T-Shirt. I have a number of thicker, long sleeved ones and I absolutely love them, mainly for the unmatched odor management. This T-Shirt didn't disappoint - it works as well as the other smart wool pieces of clothing I have. If you don't like how you smell in synthetic T-shirt after you work up a sweat on that steep approach, I strongly recommend you try wool - it's simply unbelievable. If the prices of wool clothes were not as high I would wear wool every day.
I'm not sure what other reviewers complaining about the small size of the bag are trying to fit in it; I am able to put in it my BlackDiamond Contact crampons and have quite a bit of room left.
The bag works as advertised.