Me828 wrote a review of Metolius Yosemite Chalk Bag on December 2, 2009
It is hard to have a chalk bag that does a bad job, but this one has extra perks. There is plenty of room. I prefer the around the waist clip for reaching either hand in at any angle. The draw cord prevents chalk spills whole not climbing, and it was better priced than comparable chalk bags. And well...it is pretty and soft fabric. You shouldn't ignore aesthetics when you have a choice!
FYI it doesn't come with chalk included. Make sure to order that too.