I bought these liners mainly because BC sent me a $20 coupon and I wanted some liners for super cold days. As soon as I took them out of the box, I noticed that one of the gloves already had a small tear in the stiching. Had I paid full price, I would have sent them back, but since they only cost me $6 after shipping, I decided to suck it up. They are very comfortable though, and performed quite well considering I have only worn them once and it was -12F. If the tear gets bigger I might think about sending them back, but for $6 I am very pleased.