I've been wearing my Marmot Guide sweater for about 2 seasons now, and I love it. I tried on all the major brands, North Face, Mountain Hardwear, Patagonia, and this one fit extremely well. I'm 5'11" medium build and the medium fit perfectly. You can lift your arms and the jacket stays put on your torso. I had the Mountain Hardwear sub zero first, but returned it because the collar wasn't soft on the inside, and the length of the jacket was so short I got a draft up my back (probably made that way for harnesses while belaying). The Marmot Guide Sweater has a longer back so you don't get drafts, a soft collar on the inside so it feels nice against your neck and chin, packs inside it's own internal pocket, and is VERY warm. I am up in the cold mountains often, and I've had this down to 0 degrees while staying toasty!

Well first let me say that I am a big guy, being an ex-college lineman has its problems,first in a bar fight they always go for you first, and second finding gear to fit you. I can say that this jacket has been awesome, fits great, I am 6'3" and 285 i have a XXL and it is the best insulating jacket/sweater I have EVER owned. Even on sub-zero days walking through downtown Chicago, I was warm. IT is lightweight and packs up nicely in the inside stuff sack/ pocket, about the size of two nalgene bottles side by side. You can wear it over a short sleeve shirt and be comfy in the coldest of weather.

This piece is fantastic. You can wear nothing but a t-shirt underneath in 15-20F weather and it will feel like it's sunny and 70F inside this jacket. I also like the fact that this down jacket is not overly bulky, like some other popular pieces I could name.

I also want to point out the ultra low-pile fleece lining around the collar. This detail *makes* the coat. I can't get over how great it feels when I've got the neck zipped to the top.

I haven't had this jacket for more than a few weeks, but I already love it. Warm, comfortable, lightweight and reasonably good looking...it really does it all for a reasonably price.

I was mainly looking for a down jacket to wear around town and under a shell for skiing from time to time, but I wasn't planning on wearing this thing backpacking. For what I was looking for, this jacket fits the bill and then some.

Pros:
1. Warm (I actually ordered 3 different jackets at the same time so I could choose the one that fit the best. It's warmer and bulkier than the Patagonia down jacket, but not bulky but just as warm as the North Face Nuptse jacket. It kind of splits that difference between bulk and warmth just perfectly in my book.)

2. Good fit (I'm 6'1" and weight 180lbs and the medium fits just right. The sleeves are long enough and the body stays in place when you raise your arms. Plenty of room to layer, but not too much as to feel like I'm wearing a garbage bag.)

3. Lightweight (As most down jackets go, this thing weighs very little. Not as light as the Patagonia, but light enough.)

4. Feels durable. (Haven't had it long enough to tell for sure, but the exterior ripstop feels like it'll hold up.)

5. Love the thermafleece lined collar and handwarmer pockets

6. Fits a little longer in length compared to Mountain Hardwear jacket I have, which is good as my waist doesn't feel exposed.

Cons:

1. Not a lot of frills. (Interior zip pockets doubles as stuff sack so it's cavernous which isn't ideal for a wallet or ipod.)

2. Zippers are so-so.

3. The look is pretty middle of the road.

Overall I love it so far. If it holds up then I give it a 5+. For the price, you really can't beat it as other jackets I tried just didn't live up in the "features/value" ratio.

OK, I don't normally take the time to respond to reviews, but this is the greatest jacket I have owned. Super comfortable, great
fit (roomy) and VERY warm. If this is the "sweater" I can't imagine how warm the "jacket" must be. No, I'm not doing a major ex-
pedition- just walking around town (in the snow and wind) and general outdoor activities-- it has been perfect. I say "buy one
today"!

I am very happy with this jacket. It is extremely comfortable and warm. I live in MN and spend alot of time outside, so I need something that keeps me warm, and this jacket does the trick. Plus, why buy a North Face down jacket when everyone else in the world seems to have one. Be original and buy Marmot!

I bought this jacket as a gift. When I bought it I was not sure what it meant by "Sweater". When it arrived quicky I might add I was thrilled. I was so happy with the response I got from the receiver. It is not only warm, but it fits great(sz large, and the fact that it is so light weight makes it even better. I would really recommend this to anyone who would like a great wearing and veritable jacket that is so comfy and does not weigh you down and feel like you are in a huge puffer jacket. Way to go Marmot!!!

I have had my old dirty Marmot Puffy coat for years this will be its 7th winter, It has held its warmth well been through the washing machine plenty of times and always comes back for more, I was going to buy a new on this but I guess I will save my cash it is ready for another season. I is a snug fit for a puffy.

great quality

this jacket is great for traveling around nyc this time of year its light weight and not to bulky like other down jackets ive had in the past. and the price ufaa!!! you cant beat back counrty for the bargins

pack this baby on any trip where the unexpected could be waiting.