I bought this coat, even after reading the above review, and I think it is great! This is NOT like an aerodynamic, slickery-shaped, athletic-cut jacket from Arcteryx (although I think that the Kavu craftsmanship could definitely learn something from Arc'tery tighter stitching and seams), but it is perfect for what it is comfortable and durable. The canvas body is roomy enough to hide your digital SLR inside during a brief squall, or to just veil your burly Schwarzenegger chest from the covey of female Yosemite park rangers. The curly fur inside is soft and warm - but it does melt quite quickly when exposed to rather large camp fires infused with black powder and strontium. This coat is not meant to get soaked. It is not a shell. It is for dragging logs, fixing the car, and occasionally playing soccer against a bunch of fleet-footed teenagers in a sleet storm.

I am 6'1" about 180ish, okay 185 dripping wet, and this jacket was too big around the body. The arm length was perfect and the quilted sleeves and fleece-like interior was very comfy. Ultimately, I returned the jacket because of the body fit. Maybe I should have waited until I put on my winter "coat"!