Worked for me
These lasted for about 2 years of 2-3x/week use outside for the half year climbing season around here. I don't get too crazy, moderate trad and no higher than 5.10 sport, and they worked well for me. The toes wore out pretty quickly, though that may have had more to do with my stellar (hah) footwork than the shoes. Comfortable right out of the box, and I never noticed the stink that people below mentioned (and my feet are usually pretty ripe). There are better shoes out there but for the price I was pleased.