Off to a great start!
First of all, they seem true to size for me. With most of my transportation being on foot I needed something that could withstand the city sidewalks better than the sole-less UGGS and so far these are doing the trick. I've worn them through rain and snow and my feet stayed dry. I also find them to be comfy enough to wear all day at work where I am on my feet 90% of the day. I did buy some shoe inserts though for days that I know I will be on my feet much longer and doing more walking than the usual. They seem to hold up pretty well and are very warm. The inside, though not fluffy like UGGS is still very soft. I have large calves too (about 18 inches) so there's some slight gapping at the top when I lace them and I think I will have to get longer laces in the long run. Note that the sock looking portion is NOT stretchy. Overall, I am pleased with this purchase.