Make up your own mind!
Most everyone that writes reviews act as if their advertising for said company. This feature and that doohiky make this item the bomb! Bottom line is functionality. This jacket is 100% waterproof, windproof, and idiot proof. Pockets hold stuff and keep your stuff dry. Powder skirt is a little wimpy, but then again you can't have everything perfect. I really like this jacket for me. Make up your own mind.