The weather in NYC has been pretty mild but I've been wearing it for a couple of weeks now and it's kept me warm so far. It looks like it is very well made and I love the fleece at the wrists. The only qualm I had is with the color of the coat. I got the coat in black but it's navy blue, not black. Lucky for me I like navy blue so I kept it. I went to a retailer than sells the Marmot and all the "black" coats were navy blue.