Decent so far
**Update** So I'm my second season with these mitts and I have to say I'm really impressed. They've withstood some abuse and they still look and work great. I lost the mitten liners somewhere along the lines, but I never used them anyway (always glove liners). When I need new Gore-tex mitten shells, I'll be buying these again.
These mitts are the first non Burton Gore Tex Mitts I've bought in years. Unfortunately, the material seems less rugged than the Burton ones. I like how these are a true mitten, unlike the burton ones that have finger seperators that take up lots of space. And my only real complaint is that the liners are mitten shaped also, which I think should be specified. I like the glove liners better, but anything that I can easily remove and throw in the wash is important to me (liners are crutical in saving the shells from smelling horrible) Overall I think these mittens will be okay. We'll see come May.