Decent Shoe with Reservations
I was drawn to this shoe b/c of the price point. It's one of the only sub $200 shoes for winter road cycling. I've had my pair for two years now. And they are pretty good. But, these are NOT deep winter shoes. They will take you down to about freezing. And that will also require thick wool socks. While they do have Gore-tex, making them nicely waterproof, there is very little if any insulation (eg, Thinsulate). This is my biggest problem with these shoes: not warm enough. I was looking for an all winter solution in these and to that degree they really don't cut it. But, if you live in an area where it doesn't go below around 45 degrees, these might be for you.
BTW, the fit on these is pretty much true to size. But as with most winter shoes, you might want to go up a half to full size to accommodate thicker socks.