Take my review with a grain of salt, I may just have a weird body type. This shirt was great in every way, but it didn't fit at all. I'm 5'10", 135 lbs, thin/athletic build. I tried on a S, M, and L. The small fit most everywhere, but it was way too wide in the shoulders. The medium was a little loose, and the shoulders could have hidden a small set of wings. The large was well, just too big.
As I said, it might just be my weird body type, but this shirt didn't fit me in the shoulders, while most others do.
aside form the weird fit, this shirt is awesome in just about every way. It even comes in clementine, the best color you'll ever see in a shirt.