Awesome all around shoe
I've had a pair for close to a year now. I wear them for everything. Serious scrambling, biking, multi-day hiking, approaches, kayaking, work. You name it, I grab these shoes first. While they aren't waterproof, they do a decent job of repelling water when I'm getting in and out of my kayak or in light rain. Even water they have great traction on the rocks; this is what I love about them the most. They are pretty tough too. I destroyed a pair of Merrells in a single day hike and a pair of TNF hikers on a weekend trip, but these have held up to all the abuse I could throw at it for the last year.
The only thing I can knock it for is long-term comfort. They are comfortable for most events, but by mile 18 of a hike, my feet are a little sore in these. However, I haven't owned a shoe that I could hike more than 8 miles without my feet hurting. I think I'm going to try some inserts.
If you are on the fence about this shoe, get it. You will be happy.