5 stars if it was windproof
I've had this jacket for a year (looking forward to wearing it for another NE winter) and I love it. It's super warm, it almost beats my ECWCS parka and liner (Gen II Level VI).
It's pretty wind resistant, but there's this spot on the left arm where the wind just cuts right through it. I need to contact BC and figure out what's going on there.
It's also pretty sweet looking, bonus points there.