Some say the fit to size and some say they...
Some say the fit to size and some say they run big.
I wear a size 8 religiously (my running shoes, hiking boots, sandals, and even my slippers are a size 8). What size boot should I get?
I'd go with the 8. I went a size smaller and it was snug.
The discrepancy may be due to what kind of socks these folks are wearing with the boots vs. their normal shoes. I'm a 5.5 and I tried these boots on in store with running socks and the size 6 seemed too big. When I got home, I tried them on with my thick wool socks and the 6 was perfect.